As May arrives, the rhythm of the school year shifts. The classrooms are full of energy and exhaustion with lengthy To-Do lists, final assessments, field trips and the emotional weight of saying goodbye to students and another year. But amid the end-of-year whirlwind lies a quiet opportunity for instructional coaches: the chance to leave behind lasting feedback that matters.
Not only do teachers bring unique personalities, preferences and emotional landscapes into coaching relationships, but how coaches give feedback can be just as important as what is said. Effective feedback isn’t one-size-fits-all – it’s a language. And effective coaches are multilingual – not necessarily in spoken languages, but in feedback styles.
A multilingual coach in feedback styles can read the emotional climate of the moment, adapt their feedback delivery to meet the teacher’s needs, build trust through feedback personalization rather than prescription and understand that how you say something matters as much as what you say. These coaches don’t just offer feedback — they speak growth fluently.
What does the research show?
Research shows that timely, meaningful feedback is a cornerstone of professional growth. Hattie and Timperley (2007) in “The Power of Feedback” assert that feedback is one of the most powerful influences on learning — if it is clear, goal-oriented and actionable. However, for feedback to land, it also has to be received, which means it must be delivered in a way that resonates emotionally and relationally.
Inspired by Chapman and White’s “5 Languages of Appreciation in the Workplace” (2012), this article introduces The 5 Languages of Coaching Feedback — a flexible framework for delivering feedback that aligns with teachers’ individual preferences, personalities and contexts. By tuning into what each teacher needs, coaches can offer feedback that is more likely to be received and remembered, leading to authentic professional growth.
This framework builds on the coaching foundations I explored in an earlier piece, “Unlocking Growth: The Power of Coaching Tools — Human, Video, and AI,” where I discussed how multi-modal coaching strategies can enhance feedback.
The 5 Languages of Coaching Feedback
This framework reframes coaching feedback as a flexible, personalized communication tool that honors the diversity of how educators grow best. The power of the 5 Languages of Coaching Feedback framework lies not just in knowing what they are but in knowing when and with whom to use them.
1. Noticing and Naming (Words of Affirmation)
Coaches share thoughtful verbal or written acknowledgment of a teacher’s effective practice, mindset or growth. This feedback language focuses on naming strengths and intentionality by reinforcing growth, building confidence, highlighting what works and inviting reflection.
This language is best for:
- Teachers who need encouragement or a confidence boost.
- Teachers are trying something new and are unsure if it is “working.”
- Educators who are quiet contributors may go unnoticed.
- Teachers in emotionally heavy seasons (e.g., overwhelm, burnout).
- Relationship-oriented teachers who value connection.
- Any educator making incremental progress deserves recognition.
3 examples of coach moves with this language include:
- Leaving a note on a teacher’s desk highlighting a specific success.
- Using a coaching log to document and revisit “growth snapshots” over time.
- Quoting a student’s positive feedback about the teacher and sharing it directly.
2. Tangible Tools (Resource-Based Feedback)
Coaches provide relevant, well-matched tools, templates, resources or exemplars that support a teacher’s goals. This feedback language saves teachers’ time, increases clarity and helps teachers move from insight to action.
This language is best for:
- Teachers are short on time or mental bandwidth.
- Educators who want “something I can use tomorrow.”
- Highly organized or systems-driven teachers.
- Teachers implement something new, like an idea, a curriculum or an initiative.
- Teachers who value clear steps, visuals or examples.
- Educators ask for help operationalizing big ideas.
3 examples of coach moves with this language include:
- Sharing a curated template (e.g., exit ticket, discussion rubric, reflection form).
- Creating a clickable strategy menu with 3-5 options that match the teacher’s needs.
- Creating or sharing a short instructional video modeling a target practice.
3. Thoughtful support (acts of service)
Coaches show up with hands-on help, such as co-planning, co-teaching, organizing or modeling instruction. This feedback language demonstrates partnership and builds trust by showing “I’m with you,” not “I’m watching you.”
This language is best for:
- Teachers overwhelmed with tasks, testing or deadlines.
- New teachers are still building routines and systems.
- Educators implementing high-effort strategies (e.g., stations, projects).
- Relationship-building moments where trust is still forming.
- Teachers with large or high-needs classrooms.
- Times when action is more valuable than advice.
3 examples of coach moves with this language include:
- Co-planning a lesson or unit or sharing the note-taking load.
- Modeling part of a lesson while the teacher observes and reflects.
- Providing classroom coverage so the teacher can observe a peer.
4. Listening and presence (quality time)
Coaches create space for reflection, active listening and nonjudgmental conversation. This feedback language promotes psychological safety and trust, which are essential for growth. Sometimes, teachers need to be heard before they are ready to act.
This language is best for:
- Reflective educators who process through dialogue.
- Educators who value voice and autonomy.
- Teachers feel disconnected or unseen.
- Educators in emotionally complex seasons (e.g., change, burnout).
- Teachers who hesitate to speak up in group settings.
- Anyone who needs to decompress before moving forward.
3 examples of coach moves with this language include:
- Offering a confidential space to vent, process, or brainstorm.
- Letting the teacher guide the coaching conversation flow and using paraphrasing and summarizing key points to allow teachers to think.
- Holding a “coffee and coaching” chat with no agenda.
5. Growth conversations (challenge with care)
Coaches gently push teachers’ thinking through thought-provoking questions, limiting beliefs, data analysis, or reflective dialogue. This feedback language invites insights, stretches thinking, builds capacity, and shifts mindsets because quality coaching isn’t just supportive — it’s developmental.
This language is best for:
- High-performing teachers who want to keep growing.
- Teachers are ready for advanced work or next-level practice.
- Educators with a strong trust foundation with you as the coach.
- Teachers are coasting or craving a new challenge.
- Teachers are open to self-inquiry.
- Year-end goal setting or reflection conversations.
3 examples of coach moves with this language include:
- Talking through a reflective dilemma: “What’s working? What’s not? What’s next?”
- Guiding transformation by pushing gently with open questions like “What would it take to level this up?”
- Encouraging deep thinking by using a micro video or data snippet to invite self-observation.
Which feedback language is best for you?
Each of the 5 languages above represents a different “dialect” that communicates support, affirmation, or challenge in a way that resonates with the individual in front of you. No single feedback method will work with every teacher in every context.
We don’t all speak the same feedback language. One teacher may light up from a kind word, while another needs a concrete resource or a thoughtful question to feel supported. Instructional coaches must become multilingual in delivering feedback — and these five languages can help. By tapping into these languages, coaches can close the year with intention — offering support, reflection, encouragement and momentum that carries far beyond May.
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
Subscribe to SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters to see the latest hot topics on educational leadership in ASCD and ASCDLeaders. They’re among SmartBrief’s more than 200 industry-focused newsletters.