Some 73% of marketers expect fandom to play a bigger role in social strategy by 2026, per We Are Social’s latest Think Forward report – but the rules are changing. If fandom was once about consuming and amplifying content, it’s now about fans creating, reshaping and owning the narrative around it.
The shift is clear: fandom is moving from audience to author.
Social media still is the main stage, but obsession is no longer the headline act; ownership is. Fans aren’t waiting for official narratives; they’re building their own, creating lore, rewriting storylines, forming subcultures, and pushing their favorites into new cultural territory.
For brands, this shift toward fan ownership unfolds in three stages:
- Giving loyal fans access.
- Inviting them into the creative process.
- Putting them at the center of the story.
Reward loyal fans with real access
Co-creation has traditionally happened at a distance, with fans building culture among themselves, separately from the brands that own the IP. It’s participation, but at arm’s length.
That’s no longer enough. As expectations shift towards ownership, many progressive brands are starting to lift the curtain and let fans in.
A case in point is McDonald’s World Menu Heist campaign, which turned fan loyalty into cultural access. Limited-edition menus were “smuggled” into the UK by the brand’s most loyal fans, effectively making them the mechanism through which the campaign came to life.
The online speculation and excitement that followed weren’t incidental; they were driven by involvement. By giving fans a role in unlocking the experience, participation started to feel like ownership.
Working directly with your fans rather than alongside them creates stronger consumer buy-in. In this case, it turned a smart promotion into a genuinely shared cultural moment.
Invite fans into the creative process
Some brands are taking this a step further, inviting fans into the creative process itself rather than just the execution.
From SCRT x Dazed’s crowdsourced design challenges to sports brand ON’s product-testing communities, fans increasingly expect a seat at the table.
In sport, this dynamic is even more pronounced. Fandom isn’t just emotional, it’s deeply invested. The flipside is that when fans feel excluded from decisions that shape the future of what they love, the backlash is immediate.
Governing bodies, clubs and leagues are now navigating a delicate balance: attracting new audiences without alienating their core.
Some are doing this better than others. While Premier League fans have drawn battle lines against their clubs over ticket price increases and initiatives like the Super League, NASCAR has proven to be something of a shining light.
By leaning into the role fans play in shaping the sport, NASCAR has created fan councils to give them a formal voice. These councils bring together committed supporters to provide direct input on everything from race formats and rules to the live experience. It’s a clear signal that fans are more than spectators: they’re participants in how the sport evolves.
Make fans the hero of the story
The next step moves beyond just involving fans in the story, to making them the heroes of the story.
Spotify’s Fan Life campaign did exactly this, celebrating the rituals that define communities and putting them front and center of the brand’s narrative. By spotlighting global and local fandoms, it brought audiences closer together and unlocked the kind of advocacy brands are chasing.
Where Spotify focused on shared rituals, others are leaning into individual stories that give fandom its emotional depth. Hinge’s No Ordinary Love campaign centers on real fan experiences, showing how everyday devotees can become a brand’s most powerful cultural ambassadors.
Sharing the stage
Fandom drives advocacy for brands in a way awareness alone never can. But that advocacy only deepens when fans feel a genuine stake in what a brand stands for, and where it’s going.
The brands that benefit most from this shift won’t be the ones trying to control fandom from the sidelines. They’ll be the ones willing to share the stage.
Whether that’s offering real access, inviting fans into the creative process, or putting them at the center of the story, the opportunity is the same: turning audiences into communities that feel a sense of ownership over what happens next.
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
If you liked this article, sign up for the SmartBrief Marketing Pulse, a daily look at the latest in shifts and performance data for marketers.