Across the country, district and school administrators are navigating a complex set of challenges: persistent learning loss, staffing shortages in high-needs schools and classrooms and the daily reality of teacher absenteeism. Even in districts where full-time vacancies have begun to stabilize, the average teacher still misses approximately 9.4 days of school per year — roughly 5% of a 187-day school calendar.
This translates to students spending the equivalent of an entire academic year under the instruction of a substitute teacher by the time they graduate from high school. The impact on continuity, engagement and instructional quality is clear — but until now, substitute educators have operated with little to no formal performance standards or professional development.
Rethinking substitute teacher preparation
When substitute educators are underprepared, the result is more than classroom disruption. It creates lost instructional time and inconsistent learning experiences that widen achievement gaps. To address this, district and school leaders must rethink how they prepare substitute educators, focusing on high-quality training grounded in clear, research-backed standards.
Models like the Kelly Education LEARN Framework create a professional standard of practice for every substitute, regardless of assignment duration or district location. They transform substitute teaching from a reactive role into a proactive profession and help align substitute contributions with district goals for instructional quality.
Actionable steps for district leaders
States, including Missouri and Wisconsin, are now requiring licensing for substitute teachers and implementing a standards-based training framework that professionalizes substitute teaching and improves educational outcomes. Steps to guide your district’s efforts include:
- Recognize the impact of substitute educators on teaching and learning. Understand and acknowledge substitute educators as essential contributors to academic success by embedding high standards into their roles. Promote their value as part of the educational team to build respect and trust across the district. “When staff members achieve great outcomes for students or demonstrate exceptional service, we recognize and celebrate them. This isn’t just a feel-good activity — it’s essential for sustaining motivation and commitment,” Dan Sims, superintendent of Bibb County School District in Georgia, said during a recent interview on the ”Wake Up and Teach” podcast.
- Assess and evaluate current training programs. Review existing substitute training initiatives to identify any deficiencies in rigor, relevance or alignment with district goals. Use evidence-based standards to evaluate their effectiveness in addressing key areas like instructional quality, classroom management and student engagement. Sims added that “comprehensive wellness must be interwoven into everything that happens throughout our buildings. Every school engages in wellness activities, and we regularly assess the impact of our practices to inspire continuous improvement.”
- Establish or adopt districtwide standards. Create consistent guidelines for substitute expectations, including performance, professional behavior and classroom impact. Align these standards across schools for uniformity and clarity. When it comes to professional development on districtwide standards, Sims said, “[w]e assess where teachers are in relation to student needs, then channel professional development accordingly. This ensures that everyone receives what they actually need and that we all stay aligned with student outcomes.”
- Define measurable outcomes. Develop clear metrics for tracking the impact of substitute training. Use tools like classroom feedback, retention rates and student performance data to assess progress and inform continuous improvements. In Bibb County, Sims said, “[w]e don’t conduct evaluations for evaluation’s sake. Instead, we use these tools as opportunities for growth and development, providing feedback that helps staff members return the next day better prepared to excel.”
- Vet training providers. Research and compare training providers to ensure their programs meet rigorous, research-based criteria. Focus on offerings with measurable outcomes, such as improved substitute performance and student success.
By following these steps, district leaders can elevate the role of substitute educators, ensure they are well-prepared and position them to make a lasting impact on student learning and success.
In today’s schools, substitute teachers play a crucial role in a student’s educational journey, often stepping in during key moments to ensure learning continues without interruption. Their development has often been overlooked. By investing in structured, research-driven training, districts can equip substitute educators to play an active role in advancing student success.
Redefining substitute teachers as essential contributors — not temporary solutions — improves instructional continuity, minimizes disruptions and ensures that every teaching day matters. With strategic vision and dedicated leadership, districts can transform substitute educators into educators who leave a lasting impact on student achievement.
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
Subscribe to SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters to see the latest hot topics on educational leadership in ASCD and ASCDLeaders. They’re among SmartBrief’s more than 200 industry-focused newsletters.