“Curiosity” is one of today’s most celebrated leadership traits. It’s in keynote speeches. It’s on competency models. It’s a top development goal for many forward-thinking leaders. Rightfully so — curiosity fuels innovation, transformation, adaptability and trust.
But here’s the catch: many leaders who want to embody curiosity inadvertently undermine it. How? With one familiar, well-intentioned phrase:
“I’m curious, but…”
It sounds open. It sounds thoughtful. It even sounds humble. But in practice, it often functions as a subtle pivot — from possibility to pushback, from interest to evaluation. It quietly signals that a decision may already be made, or that you’re about to redirect, challenge or close the conversation.
And that’s a problem. Because in 2026, when transformation is constant, and input must be rapid and inclusive, leadership language matters more than ever.
“Curious, but…” – What it really signals
The phrase “I’m curious, but…” tends to show up in conversations where there’s tension between a leader’s desire to be open and their instinct to stay in control.
- “I’m curious, but have you considered the risks?”
- “I’m curious, but didn’t we already try this?”
- “I’m curious, but how would that even work?”
Each of these may be valid thoughts. But when packaged in “curious, but…,” they often land as dismissal — not dialogue. Team members hear: You’re skeptical. You’ve already decided. This door is closing.
Even more importantly, it dampens future contributions. Over time, people stop bringing half-formed ideas, provocative perspectives or risky insights. Which means fewer chances for innovation, problem-solving or meaningful growth.
Why it matters now
Curiosity isn’t a soft skill. It’s a strategic capacity — especially in today’s landscape of rapid transformation. When curiosity is real — and sustained — it helps leaders:
- Surface insights and opportunities others might miss
- Lead change with empathy and flexibility
- Create psychological safety for experimentation
- Encourage teams to challenge, adapt, and grow
But when curiosity is performative or short-circuited by a “but,” these benefits vanish.
Flip the script: From “but” to “and”
The simplest way to strengthen your curiosity muscle? Change the conjunction.
Swap “but” for “and.”
- “I’m curious — and I’d love to hear more about how you got there.”
- “I’m curious — and I wonder how you envision this might play out.”
- “I’m curious — and think this is worth exploring before we decide.”
“And” expands. “But” contracts. “And” keeps the door open. “But” closes it.
Even when you need to challenge an idea or redirect a conversation, anchoring in genuine curiosity before introducing constraints gives ideas room to breathe and bloom — and signals that contributions are safe and valued.
Try these curiosity-driven leadership moves
If you want to lead with more authentic curiosity, here are five high-impact shifts:
- Pause before reacting. Give yourself a moment to reflect before responding — especially when an idea feels incomplete or risky.
- Ask questions you don’t know the answer to. Too often, leaders ask questions to confirm what they already think. Flip the script — ask something that could truly surprise you. “What’s something you see that I might be missing?”
- Invite elaboration. Use prompts like “Tell me more…” or “What’s your thinking behind that?” instead of moving straight to evaluation.
- Curate tension, not consensus. Rather than aiming for immediate alignment, invite diverse views early. “Let’s pressure-test this idea — what’s the strongest counterpoint we haven’t considered yet?”
- Leave space in meetings. Literally. End team meetings five minutes early and pose a single question — then go silent. Let curiosity fill the space instead of directives. “What are we not talking about that we probably should be?”
Lock in new leadership language
Your expertise will always be valuable. But in 2026, it’s your curiosity that creates space for trust, innovation and performance your organization needs. So, resolve to shift your language. And the next time you hear yourself saying, “I’m curious, but…” — pause. Ask yourself: What possibility might open if I said “and” instead? And change your conjunction — to change your results.
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
____________________________________
Take advantage of SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters on leadership and business transformation, among the company’s more than 250 industry-focused newsletters.