For several years, the 4As has published its annual “look ahead” report in the fall, looking at trends from the previous year and insights to power agencies for the upcoming year. For 2027, the 4As took a different view on its annual report. Today and Thursday, we’ll have two-part Q&A with 4As CEO Justin Thomas-Copland, diving into the association’s new report – 4As | 4sight Briefing: The Value Reset – for agencies and the advertising industry as a whole.
Q: How did the 2027 Briefing evolve from the past 4As “Look Ahead” reports? How was it created and what purpose(s) does it serve?
Justin Thomas-Copeland: Our industry is at an inflection point. AI, in-housing, new competitors and shifting client expectations are fundamentally resetting how agency value is created, recognized and rewarded. Agencies have a choice: take an active role in redefining that value, or have it defined for them.
That’s what drove the evolution of our annual Look Ahead into 4As | 4sight 2027 Briefing: The Value Reset. We wanted to move beyond anticipating what’s next to challenging agency leaders to shape what comes next.
Built from candid conversations with CMOs, agency leaders, search consultants, creators and industry innovators, the briefing identifies four critical fault lines: client C-suite perceptions of agency value, remuneration, talent and original thinking.
We deliberately released it in October as agencies are building their 2027 plans, to provoke difficult conversations, challenge legacy assumptions and drive action. And it’s not a one-and-done report. It’s the starting point for research, tools and resources throughout 2027 to help agencies redefine and reclaim their value.
Q: Proving value, especially to client leadership, has been a hot topic of late. How can agencies “speak C-suite” to their client contacts in executive leadership?
Justin: We have to do a better job at translating discussions about our deliverables and marketing KPIs into conversations about the broader business impact agencies have, in the business language of our clients and their priorities.
The boardroom doesn’t buy activity. Their business and financial language speaks to revenue acceleration, margin and market share defense, as well as risk management.
Agencies have become exceptionally good at proving effort; we now need them to develop the commercial discipline to prove impact. The brief for agency CEOs is to broker and lead these conversations with the most senior clients. A missing part of becoming fluent in your clients’ language is access to their bigger picture priorities and overall business focus. This allows you to situate your value and impact in their business.
This means proactively engaging the CFO and procurement on their terms, establishing shared business KPIs and treating any loss of C-suite access as a critical commercial alarm. If the client’s executive team can’t name your single biggest contribution to their bottom line, your agency’s seat at the table is no longer secure.
As Meghan McDonnell, CEO, Pile & Company, one of the voices featured in the 4As | 4sight briefing, put it, “The CEO and CFO aren’t as interested in the soft brand metrics. They want to understand how brand is impacting the bottom line, and agencies that can speak to business outcomes are the ones that instantly start to build the trust of the C-suite.”
Q: How can agencies reposition themselves from vendors into a more business-focused/growth relationship with clients?
Justin: Years of pursuing growth at all costs have created the vendor trap. Agencies began absorbing complex technical overhead, from adtech integration and media QA to tagging, without reflecting it on invoices or even giving visibility of these types of investments
This resulted in years of giving away high-level strategic counsel and capability just to win pitches. If you package your judgment like a throw-in, clients will price and treat you like a vendor. To shift that dynamic, agencies need to move back upstream. Strategy, media orchestration, data and creative problem-solving are where clients genuinely need guidance. Repositioning starts when you draw a hard line: stop bundling strategic thinking into commoditized execution fees.
Q: In 2027 and the following next few years, how can successful agencies differentiate themselves from competitors, whether that’s other agencies or clients taking work in-house?
Justin: If you are competing on production speed and volume, you are going to lose to AI or an in-house team. What differentiates an agency is ambition, taste and original thinking. AI makes acceptable work abundant, which means distinctive work commands a premium.
Agencies need to take the capacity that AI frees up and reinvest it into creative courage, innovation and strategic exploration. Doing something cheaper isn’t a differentiator; changing the trajectory of a client’s business is.
We spoke to Kwame Taylor-Hayford, co-founder of Kin, for his perspective on The Value Reset. He says what excites him is bringing creative problem-solving to clients and helping them think through platforms and services and ways that they can innovate and evolve their businesses into new products. “It’s an unlock in a world where so much of what we used to do is going away. ”
The agencies that will succeed are those that position themselves as strategic, creative business advisers, bringing an independent perspective that challenges clients, sharpens decisions and drives growth. That value can be delivered at any scale, from global networks to specialist firms and flexible, on-demand models built around client needs.
Q: What else about 4As 2027 Briefing should those in the agency world – and outside of it – know?
Justin: This briefing isn’t about industry rhetoric or high-level observations. It’s an operational call to action.
That is a strategic choice we have made. Agencies are in the middle of this inflection point and our role is to help them wayfind to value creation. And to give them the confidence to have partner-level conversations with clients. We also wanted to give perspective across the fault lines, allowing for them to have a sense of where they sit and what they need to pay attention to in their FY planning.
The structural shifts we see, including collapsing production costs, procurement tightening and the rise of in-housing, are today’s operating realities. For shops running on legacy inertia, this looks like an existential squeeze. But for leaders ready to redesign their business models, it’s an incredible opportunity. This briefing gives leadership teams the diagnostic questions and actionable levers they need to reset their operations and commercial terms before clients and market forces make those decisions for them.
Tune in on Thursday for part two.
If you liked this article, sign up to receive a daily dose of agency insights and news with the 4As SmartBrief newsletter.