Ask almost any manager whether strategy is about saying no, and the manager will agree. Ask whether their organization is good at it, and the answer changes.
McKinsey’s Strategy Champions research, which we draw on in our book, “Strategy and Value,” asked companies to rate themselves on 28 strategy capabilities. Deprioritizing was the only one where more companies rated themselves weak than strong. It was also the only one where even the top-performing fifth of companies came out net negative.
This is not for lack of advice. Peter Drucker urged “purposeful abandonment” and called abandoning yesterday the first policy of any organization that wants to lead change. Michael Porter made trade-offs part of the definition of strategy, writing that “the essence of strategy is choosing what not to do.” Steve Jobs told Fortune that focus means “saying no to the hundred other good ideas.” Jim Collins found that the companies he studied made equal use of stop-doing lists and to-do lists.
Why the advice hasn’t stuck
In our experience, the idea lives in how we define strategy, but rarely in the strategies we actually write. Most strategies state what to pursue: the markets to enter, the customers to win, the capabilities to build. What those choices displace goes unsaid, and so it carries on. Few strategies name what will stop, and fewer are sent back for leaving it out.
That is why the idea needs to move from advice to a standard. People can admire and ignore a principle. A periodic review can lapse. A standard is much harder to skip. A.G. Lafley, the former chief executive of Procter & Gamble, wrote in Harvard Business Review that one of the few jobs only a CEO can do is to shape an organization’s values and standards, the expectations that guide its decisions. Strategy deserves its own standard. In our book, we lay one out, and one requirement is that a strategy names what will stop. A strategy that names only what it will pursue is closer to a wish list.
Lafley was writing about chief executives, but any manager who sets direction for a team can do the same. Strategy is loosely defined, and most teams never agree on what it requires. That leaves managers free to define it for their own teams: Our strategy is not finished until every choice in it names what will stop.
Why AI raises the stakes
The standard matters more now, because AI makes starting almost free. A proposal, an analysis or a prototype that once took weeks can be produced in an afternoon. In recent conversations with strategy leaders, we have heard the same two complaints: a tidal wave of new ideas, and proposers more convinced than ever that theirs is right.
Research suggests why. A study published this year in Science found that 11 leading AI models affirmed users’ actions 49% more often than people did, and that a single interaction with an agreeable chatbot left participants more convinced they were right. The study concerned personal disputes, not work projects, but the pattern is familiar. When every idea arrives polished, and its owner arrives convinced, saying no becomes harder and more necessary. A standard helps here, too. A no is easier to give, and to accept, when it follows from what every strategy requires rather than from one manager’s view of one person’s idea.
How to put the standard to work
In research across more than 400 companies, which we described in Harvard Business Review this summer, precision about what will stop was one of three actions that helped companies act on a new strategy. Four practices help:
- Don’t call a strategy finished until it names what stops. For each choice your team makes, write down what you will stop to make room for it. If that line is blank, the choice isn’t finished.
- Move the resources, not just the words. When something stops, shift the time, money and people it was using to the choices that matter most.
- Hear the case before you decide. Ideas built with AI often rest on a case only their owner fully understands. Ask the person to explain it in their own words, then judge the idea, not the person.
- End with two lists. Close every strategy discussion by writing down what you will do and what you will not, and share both.
None of this requires permission from the top. It requires a manager willing to hold strategy to a higher bar. The case for saying no has been made for decades. What has been missing is a standard that puts it inside the strategy itself. Hold your next strategy to it.
