Instructional coaching is a dynamic and complex process, both an art and a science, blending human connection, intuition and adaptability with research-based strategies and data-informed decision-making.
- The Art: Coaching requires relationship-building, empathy and communication skills to engage teachers in reflective conversations. Each coaching interaction is unique, requiring adaptability, creativity and emotional intelligence to meet educators where they are.
- The Science: Effective coaching uses evidence-based instructional practices, data analysis and structured frameworks to guide teacher growth. Coaches use models like coaching cycles, performance metrics and research-backed strategies to drive measurable improvement.
To be effective, instructional coaches must develop various skills and strategies in both areas.
What happens if coaching becomes imbalanced towards the art or science side of coaching, not both?
Instructional coaching as an art
If coaching is only an art:
Strengths:
- Builds strong relationships and trust
- Encourages reflective conversations
- Allows for flexibility and responsiveness to teacher needs
Challenges:
- Lacks measurable impact without data-driven decisions
- It may feel too abstract or inconsistent
- Can lead to unstructured coaching without clear goals or accountability
Risk: Coaching becomes intuitive but ineffective, relying too much on personal rapport without concrete instructional improvement.
Instructional coaching as a science
If coaching is only a science:
Strengths:
- Grounded in research and data
- Provides clear goals, structure and accountability
- Focuses on measurable teacher and student progress
Challenges:
- Can feel rigid and impersonal
- Ignores the human element of motivation, emotions and relationships
- Teachers may feel overwhelmed, micromanaged or disengaged
Risk: Coaching becomes mechanical and transactional, focusing too much on data and compliance while failing to inspire lasting change.
The best approach balances both
Instructional coaching is most effective when it integrates both art and science. It leverages human-centered relationships and intuition while also using data and structured goals to achieve sustainable instructional improvement and drive meaningful change.
This A-to-Z guide incorporates both the art and science of coaching. From active listening to zeroing in on teacher needs, these 26 coaching essentials will help you refine your coaching practice and maximize impact.
| The Art of Coaching | The Science of Coaching |
| A – Active Listening
B – Building Relationships E – Effective Feedback F – Facilitating Reflection H – Honoring Teacher Expertise I – Inquiry-Based Coaching J – Job-Embedded Support K – Knowledge Sharing N – Navigating Resistance P – Professional Learning Communities Q – Questioning for Deeper Thinking T – Trust-Building Z – Zeroing in on Teacher Needs |
C – Coaching Cycles
D – Data-Informed Decisions G – Goal Setting L – Learning Walks M – Metrics to Demonstrate Coaching Performance and Impact O – Observational Coaching R – Reflection Journals S – Strengths-Based Coaching U – Using Protocols V – Video Coaching W – Writing Grants X – eXamining Impact Y – Yearlong Support |
A – Active Listening
Active listening is a critical coaching skill that fosters trust and open communication by ensuring teachers feel heard. Coaches can enhance understanding by using reflective questioning and paraphrasing, leading to deeper, more productive conversations.
B – Building Relationships
Strong relationships lay the foundation for collaboration and meaningful change. Demonstrating empathy, consistency and celebrating small wins helps build relationships and trust with teachers and administrators.
C – Coaching Cycles
Structured coaching cycles guide teachers in self-reflection and instructional improvement. Using structured coaching cycle models like Jim Knight’s Impact Cycle (Identify, Learn, Improve) ensures coaching remains focused, actionable and sustainable by establishing clear touchpoints for goal setting, implementation and feedback to ensure coaching efforts are sustained and impactful.
D – Data-Informed Decisions
Coaching is most effective when it is grounded in data. Analyzing student performance and observational data allows coaches to tailor support and drive meaningful instructional improvements.
E – Effective Feedback
Timely, specific and actionable feedback empowers teachers to improve their practice. When done well, feedback helps balance strengths with areas for growth, making it both constructive and motivating. While there is not one right way to share feedback, research provides insights into what makes feedback meaningful in the form of feedback guidelines.
F – Facilitating Reflection
Encouraging teachers to analyze their practice fosters self-awareness and growth. Inviting video data, human coaching and AI data into the conversation makes reflection richer and deeper.
G – Goal Setting
Clear, measurable goals provide direction and accountability. Using SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) goals ensures teachers stay focused on instructional improvement.
H – Honoring Teacher Expertise
Recognizing teachers’ knowledge fosters mutual respect and collaboration. Coaches can empower teachers by acknowledging strengths and inviting them to share best practices and solve problems.
I – Inquiry-Based Coaching
Guiding teachers through questioning rather than directives encourages deeper thinking and ownership. Asking inquiry-based questions like “What evidence do you see that students are engaged?” promotes self-reflection and problem-solving in inquiry-based coaching.
J – Job-Embedded Support
Coaching is most effective when it happens in real-time. Providing modeling, co-teaching and immediate feedback in teachers’ daily routines makes learning practical and impactful.
K – Knowledge Sharing
Instructional coaches serve as a bridge to new research, best practices and teacher classroom success stories. Sharing articles, podcasts and case studies keeps teachers informed and inspired to innovate.
L – Learning Walks
Non-evaluative classroom visits help coaches and teachers identify patterns and instructional strengths. Using structured observation tools and debriefing findings fosters a culture of continuous improvement.
M – Metrics to Demonstrate Coaching Performance and Impact
Measuring coaching effectiveness through goal-setting, student outcomes and teacher proficiency ensures accountability and alignment with school-wide goals. Tracking teacher progress, student achievement and structured reflections provide data-driven insights for continuous improvement.
N – Navigating Resistance
Addressing reluctance to change requires empathy and strategic support. Coaches can encourage buy-in by listening to concerns, validating feelings and introducing manageable steps to ease transitions.
O – Observational Coaching
Using classroom observations provides real-time data for teacher growth. Coaches should focus on descriptive feedback over evaluation, ensuring a constructive approach.
P – Professional Learning Communities (PLCs)
Collaborative teacher groups enhance instructional improvement. Facilitating discussions on student work and best practices through PLC coaching fosters shared learning.
Q – Questioning for Deeper Thinking
Encouraging reflective questioning helps teachers refine their choices, and effective coaching questions challenge assumptions and promote meaningful inquiry.
R – Reflection Journals
Structured reflection fosters deeper learning, encouraging teachers and coaches to document successes, challenges and insights to enhance their professional growth.
S – Strengths-Based Coaching
Leveraging teacher strengths boosts confidence and motivation by identifying and building on existing skills to enhance instructional effectiveness.
T – Trust-Building
A safe coaching environment fosters honest dialogue. Being transparent, reliable and nonjudgmental strengthens professional relationships.
U – Using Protocols
Protocols provide structured, research-based approaches to guide coaching discussions, collaboration, and instructional decision-making. Implementing established protocols ensure consistency, equity and focus in coaching conversations while keeping discussions goal-oriented and actionable.
V – Video Coaching
Recorded lessons allow for self-reflection and growth for both teacher and instructional coaches and the practice of reviewing video footage together offers objective insights into instructional and coaching practices.
W – Writing Grants to Fund Educational Projects and Innovation
Grant writing helps secure funding for instructional initiatives, technology and professional development that may not be available through traditional budgets.
X – eXamining Impact
Assessing coaching effectiveness ensures meaningful change. Using surveys, reflections and data reviews keeps coaching targeted and results-driven.
Y – Yearlong Support
Sustained coaching from start of year to end of year leads to lasting instructional change. Implementing ongoing coaching cycles and check-ins ensures continuous improvement.
Z – Zeroing in on Teacher Needs
Customizing coaching based on teacher strengths and challenges improves engagement. Using surveys, observations and one-on-one conversations tailors support to individual educators.
Key strategies for meaningful change
Effective instructional coaching is both an art and a science. By integrating these 26 key strategies, coaches can create meaningful, sustainable change in schools and classrooms. Which of these coaching ideas will you implement first to improve your instructional coaching?
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
Subscribe to SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters to see the latest hot topics on educational leadership in ASCD and ASCDLeaders. They’re among SmartBrief’s more than 200 industry-focused newsletters.