Heritage brands rarely lose relevance because they become old; they lose relevance because they gradually stop expressing what made them extraordinary in the first place. This almost never happens all at once – it’s a gradual slide.
A campaign becomes a little safer. A visual system becomes a little more generic. New leaders arrive with new priorities. Agencies change. Teams expand. Decisions that once belonged to a founder become shared across committees as the company grows and evolves with new team members and needs. Every choice feels reasonable in isolation. However, over time, the brand begins to drift.
The drift is not away from its customers; it is away from itself. Brands don’t wake up and decide to become ordinary. It happens one reasonable decision at a time.
So, what happens?
When organizations begin to feel their brands slipping, the instinct is often to jump to creative: a new identity, a new campaign, new website, etc. However, the big looming mistake is deciding on the answer before fully understanding the problem.
The first question should never be: “What should we create?” It should be: “What has changed?” Has the market evolved? Has culture shifted? Have customer expectations changed? Has the competitive landscape moved? Has the brand’s distinctive advantage become more relevant? Or less?
And perhaps most importantly: What equity is still worth protecting for this brand? Only then can you determine whether the brand needs to reaffirm its positioning, refine it or rethink it altogether.
Everything else follows.
A look at Tacori
When my agency first partnered with Tacori in 2007, the luxury jewelry category had settled into a familiar visual language. Celebrity endorsements and aspirational imagery had become the norm, making one brand increasingly difficult to distinguish from another. While Tacori was already respected by those who knew the brand for its exceptional craftsmanship and distinctive design, it had yet to establish the broader recognition its work deserved.
The opportunity wasn’t to reinvent Tacori. It was to clarify what made it extraordinary. We made the jewelry, rather than the celebrity, the hero. Craftsmanship became art, and everything from advertising and retail to digital, photography, collateral and the broader brand experience was organized around a single idea: celebrating the artistry behind every piece. The work helped establish Tacori as one of the most recognizable luxury jewelry brands in America, contributing to a remarkable period of growth for the company.
Eventually, our engagement came to a close.
Over the following years, Tacori continued to evolve. New campaigns were developed, new creative perspectives emerged and the luxury market itself continheritage brands, Brian Munce, Tacoriued to change.
More than a decade later, Paul Tacorian invited Gestalt back. The call was not to recreate what had come before, but to revisit the enduring ideas that had always made Tacori distinctive and ask how those same enduring ideas should be expressed for today’s luxury consumer.
How do you keep a heritage brand fresh?
Our challenge was clear: Determine what has always been true about Tacori and deserves to be true for the next 20 years?
The answer emerged after a review of the brand’s key equity: That, its extraordinary jewelry and master craftsmanship is a form of human expression that should be lived, loved and enjoyed, while recognizing how luxury consumers – and the role jewelry plays in their lives – had evolved.
That realization ultimately led us somewhere new: The Art of Tacori. A creative idea rooted in the belief that artistry doesn’t belong behind glass, it belongs in life. Where the original work celebrated craftsmanship as art to admire, The Art of Tacori reimagines that same truth as artistry meant to be worn, lived in and made meaningful by the people who choose it. The new creative is different from what came before, but is rooted in the brand’s core pillar: An appreciation for artistry, craftsmanship, emotion and the belief that exceptional jewelry becomes meaningful through the people who wear it.
Now, it was the same brand truth with a modified, updated expression. Perhaps that’s the distinction heritage brands need to understand most – Evolution doesn’t require abandoning the ideas that made you matter. It requires knowing which ideas are worth carrying forward – and having the courage to express them differently.
What are the takeaways for brands and marketers?
Brands don’t become iconic because they change with every passing trend, nor do they remain iconic by refusing to change at all. They endure because they continually rediscover what has always made them worth caring about – and find new ways to express it.
Ensuring that with every decision, the brand becomes more unmistakably itself. Because the brands that endure aren’t the ones that change the most. They’re the ones that never lose sight of who they are.
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
____________________________________
If you liked this article, sign up for the SmartBrief Marketing Pulse, a daily look at the latest in shifts and performance data for marketers.
