All Articles Education Voice of the Educator The gratitude gap: Are we thanking teachers for things that are exhausting them?

The gratitude gap: Are we thanking teachers for things that are exhausting them?

Show appreciation and gratitude for teachers this year by taking away unnecessary tasks, Donna Spangler writes.

6 min read

EducationVoice of the Educator

[Pexels]

November brings a familiar tradition to schools. Handwritten notes appear in mailboxes, treats find their way into faculty areas and heartfelt messages thank teachers for all they do.

We thank them for their flexibility, for working evenings and weekends, for going above and beyond and for doing whatever it takes to help students succeed.

And we mean every word.

But I’ve been thinking about something. What if some of the very things we’re thanking teachers for are also wearing them down?

I’ve long believed that gratitude should be part of a school’s everyday culture, and that every thank-you matters. But appreciation should also prompt us to examine what we’re asking teachers to carry.

Perhaps this Thanksgiving, one of the most meaningful ways to show gratitude isn’t to give teachers something more. Maybe it’s to take something unnecessary away.

When more support still means more work

In schools, we introduce new initiatives, assessment tools, curriculum resources, professional development and improvement plans to improve teaching and learning.

Many are worthwhile. Some are essential.

But here’s a question we don’t ask often enough: “What are we stopping to make room for what’s new?”

We often describe new initiatives as “continued work” or the “next logical step,” without letting go of the expectations that came before.

Consider a teacher using a new assessment platform while maintaining the spreadsheet it was supposed to replace. Or a PLC that spends valuable meeting time completing lengthy documentation. Social-emotional learning may begin with classroom routines, expand to schoolwide practices and eventually include additional curricula and programs.

Each requirement may have made sense when introduced. Together, they create an increasingly crowded plate.

And that plate is already full.

These aren’t isolated frustrations. They show how requirements build up when nobody steps back to look at everything teachers are being asked to do.

A 2024 Pew Research Center study found that 84% of public K-12 teachers reported not having enough time during regular work hours to complete their responsibilities. Among those teachers, 81% identified simply having too much work as a major reason.

The tendency to layer new initiatives onto already demanding workloads is a challenge I’ve explored before with educator Jessica Fields. But the question remains: “What are we willing to remove?” 

That’s the gratitude gap:  teachers hear that they are valued, but don’t always see that appreciation reflected in school actions that make their work more manageable.

Why is stopping so difficult?

Research helps explain why schools keep practices whose value is questionable or that duplicate other efforts.

In a 2023 study published in Prevention Science, researchers interviewed 24 school and district administrators about continuing underperforming prevention programs. They examined escalation of commitment: continuing to invest despite disappointing results.

Sound familiar?

Previous investments, internal pressures and hopes that more implementation support will solve problems can keep initiatives going. When something isn’t working, we often respond with more training, resources, monitoring or another year to get it right.

Sometimes that’s needed. Other times, we should question whether the practice should continue.

Researchers call this de-implementation.

In their 2026 research brief, Less Is More, Farmer, Hudson and Ward describe how to intentionally identify and discontinue low-value practices. Their GROW framework asks leaders to prepare for change, remove, reduce or replace ineffective practices, optimize implementation and monitor results.

It’s an idea worth considering, especially when a practice has outlived its original purpose or adds work. After all, we devote considerable time to implementation plans. Why not give the same attention to what we stop doing?

Five ways to close the gratitude gap

1. Notice what teachers are carrying.

Some responsibilities are so routine that nobody remembers why they started. Ask teachers which recurring tasks consume time without clear instructional value. Listen for duplication, outdated procedures and things done simply because they’ve always been done.

For example, a conversation might begin with: “What part of your week takes more time than it should?“

Before we can remove something, we have to notice it. 

2. Question the value, not just the efficiency.

When teachers struggle with workload, we often offer time-saving strategies or templates. Those supports help, but making an unnecessary task faster doesn’t make it necessary.

Consider a weekly report nobody reads or uses for instructional decisions. Rather than finding a faster way to complete it, ask why it’s required.

A useful leadership question: “If we stopped doing this tomorrow, what important outcome would we lose?“

If no one can explain its value, it may be time to reconsider.

3. Decide what to stop, reduce, or replace.

Not everything can or should be eliminated. Some responsibilities are legally required, necessary for student safety or central to instruction.

But others deserve a closer look.

Could a duplicate report stop? Could a weekly meeting become monthly? Could two overlapping processes become one?

Before introducing the next initiative, review existing expectations and decide what can go. 

Coaches can identify barriers and help gather examples; school leaders may need to approve the change. Both roles matter in this work.

Ready to put subtraction into practice? The free Workload Subtraction Ledger helps teams document what they stop, reduce, or replace, estimate time returned and communicate decisions.

4. Involve teachers and protect the time returned.

Good intentions can fall short. A school eliminates a meeting only to fill that time with another requirement. A process is streamlined, but new documentation takes its place.

Was anything gained?

Teachers need a voice in identifying unnecessary work and determining whether changes help.

We know meaningful support looks different for different educators. The same applies to workload relief.

Ask what would make the greatest difference. Then resist the urge to fill the space you’ve created.

5. Measure what was removed, not just what was added.

Schools track new initiatives, professional development, meetings and resources provided.

What if we also tracked eliminated responsibilities and time returned?

Imagine a leadership team discontinuing two duplicate documentation requirements and reducing a recurring meeting, and teachers confirming that their workload became more manageable.

Now, that’s worth celebrating.

But will the relief last?

The free companion 90-Day Follow-Through guides teams through deciding on a change, implementing it and checking results at 30, 60 and 90 days.

The goal isn’t just to announce a change. It’s to learn whether teachers experienced relief.

A different kind of Thanksgiving gift

This Thanksgiving, let’s keep writing notes, sharing treats, celebrating accomplishments and recognizing the educators who make our schools special because teachers deserve that appreciation.

But let’s ask one more question: “Over the past 90 days, what have we permanently stopped requiring teachers to do?“

If we can’t name anything, perhaps that’s a conversation worth having.

What could we eliminate or simplify? What are we holding on to that no longer serves its purpose? And what might teachers do with the time we give back?

Gratitude shouldn’t stop at recognizing how much teachers give. One meaningful way to say thank you is to give something back. Not another task, tool or initiative, but time to teach, time to think and time to do the work that matters most.